Via listenerd, a blog called Holytaco (??) posted a list of 14 songs that should never be played in a bar. Their list:
14. ALL I WANNA DO – SHERYL CROW
13. MR. BRIGHTSIDE – THE KILLERS
12. R.E.M. – IT’S THE END OF THE WORLD AS WE KNOW IT (AND I FEEL FINE)
11. DANCING QUEEN – ABBA
10. SWEET HOME ALABAMA – LYNYRD SKYNYRD
9. DON’T STOP BELIEVING – JOURNEY
8. SMOOTH – CARLOS SANTANA AND ROB THOMAS
7. HOTEL CALIFORNIA - THE EAGLES
6. I WILL SURVIVE – GLORIA GAYNOR
5. MEATLOAF – PARADISE BY THE DASHBOARD LIGHT
4. KID ROCK – BAWIDABA
3. ANYTHING BY THE BEATLES - THE BEATLES
2. PIANO MAN – BILLY JOEL
1. AMERICAN PIE – DON MCLEAN
While I don’t agree with choices/reasons that HolyTaco blog states, I do think some basic guidelines are in order. Here are my suggestions:
5. Don’t play massive medleys in the style of “Hooked-on” (classics, disco, hair metal, etc..).
4. Make the covers suit the environment. Playing any song by the Kinsey Sicks in a biker bar is probably not a good idea.
3. Don’t preach. You’re hired to entertain, not to change behavior or beliefs. Songs about quitting smoking or drinking should probably be avoided.
2. Avoid assymetrical meters, excessive polyrhythms and anything that sounds like this: Varese may have inspired Frank Zappa to write music, but as far as I can tell, he’s never been a favorite of bar patrons.
1. Never try any song you aren’t capable of singing on-key.
Bonus advice: Knowing when to tell a bad joke is an art; if you don’t have the talent, don’t try it onstage.

7 Comments
Comments feed for this article
June 19th, 2008 at 3:03 pm
Let’s see here, I will no doubt play 3 of Taco’s 14 in a bar tomorrow night. Not a very good average, pretty close to the Mendoza line. In my defense, I have in the past, played 6/14 to the best of my recall.
Regarding your suggestions:
Medleys-”Hooked On” all sucked. “Hooked On Punk” might have been interesting. I try to avoid the gimme medley, you know like 9 Chuck Berry songs, that kind of thing. It’s usually an indication of a band needing to burn time. However, one of the best live shows I’ve seen was the Carbbean All-Stars in Monterey, CA. They would do an entire set without stopping between songs. Segues of original, instrumental sections in between tunes, very effective. No heckling.
Kinsey Sicks-Was not aware of them. You are correct about the biker bar for this crew but, damn; that’s an ACT!
Preaching-Dead on right. I’ve played with guys who feel it is their duty to “witness” and I’ve witnessed that the audience takes it as condescending.
The stop drinking guy link was a hoot. 5. “High & Dry”: Why drink when you’ve got drugs? was my favorite.
Varese-Now, personally I would pay to see this in a bar or anywhere else.
Off Key-A little pitchy there Dog. There’s an art to singing out of tune and pulling it off. Study the masters.
Bad Joke-Nice one-expect retaliation.
June 19th, 2008 at 3:20 pm
Retaliation noted. Someday I’m gonna show up for one of your gigs. Seriously, it’s on my “to-do” list. Especially if the backup singers are there for “Soul Searching’”…
June 19th, 2008 at 3:43 pm
Those girls (Joy Steele, Robin Reese) can sing. I call ‘em the Hillbunnies. I use them every chance I get in the studio but, haven’t had the opportunity to do so live, yet. In this game, anybody that’s any good expects to get paid, have you noticed that?
June 20th, 2008 at 11:59 am
Hillbunnies…heh.
I thought you probably picked ‘em up at a church social.
June 20th, 2008 at 12:20 pm
Not too far off the mark. I think that the projects that I’ve got them into are among the more Secular things they’ve done. Sisters, by the way, part of the very musical Bilyeu (Big Smith is a prominent local band that features many of the family) clan.
June 25th, 2008 at 1:09 am
@Dr J: This is strange, it is the second subject I wanted to cover yesterday and I saw it covered today
The second is on guitarnoize.com
We must be somehow on the same frequency!
@Jack: I also love Soul searching, Jack!Especially the part just before the chorus, is very interesting.
June 25th, 2008 at 6:14 am
Ovidiu;–it’s an honor to be on your frequency!
